QCA 'should have found what the actual costs were': Origin

AN ENERGY company has launched court action against the Queensland Competition Authority, arguing it did not consider production costs when setting this year's electricity tariff.

Retailer Origin Energy has told the Supreme Court the QCA did not take into account the cost of producing electricity when it released its 2012-2013 tariff determination in May.

Barrister for Origin Energy, Charles Scerri QC, told the court on Monday QCA should have used a cost-based model but instead they used a market-based one.

He argued QCA did not take into account what the actual costs were in providing energy.

"They should have found what the actual costs were," he said.

"If they found out what the actual costs were - and they had plenty of submission before them about that - they would've have taken into account the (power purchase agreements) and internal generators, which are the two critical things we say they overlooked."

Mr Scerri said Origin did not criticise QCA for making a prediction but stated the flaw was not "starting with the fundamental actual costs".

Mr Scerri said if the judge could not be satisfied QCA had regard to the actual costs than the QCA's tariff decision should be quashed and sent back to the drawing board for determination.

He said QCA was not "faithful" to legal requirements and instead did what it thought was a good idea at the time.

"It's non-sensible to talk about the costs of supplying electricity if you don't have regard to the costs of producing the electricity," he said.

The State Government this year put a freeze on the household electricity tariff 11.

Origin Energy defied the move and increased their tariff but, following harsh criticism, pulled it back into line with the government directive.

The trial continues.

Topics:  origin energy queensland competition authority supreme court

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Next generation of yogis learn in the Lockyer

TUNING IN: Sarah Weber runs her kids yoga class once a week, each term from her Cura Life Studio in Gatton.

Yoga teacher Sarah Weber shares the benefits of starting yoga early.

All's Wells for Madi after third national silver medal

RISING STAR: Lockyer District Athletic Club's Madison Wells celebrates her latest silver medal success with mum Sharyn and dad Lee in Melbourne.

Madison Wells won silver at the Australian Multi-events titles.

Bid on hot cross buns to help raise funds

GOING HOT: The Old Fernvale Bakery aim to raise $40,000 for the Lady Cilento Childrens Hospital by donating $1 from every pack of hot cross buns sold. Pictured here are Lyn and Bill Rose with the latest hot cross bun creation, cranberry, pistachio and white chocolate.

Help the Old Fernvale bakery get over the line.

Local Partners