Jones, Wagners told to make progress on defamation suit

Radio personality Alan Jones is among those the Wagners are suing for defamation.
Radio personality Alan Jones is among those the Wagners are suing for defamation. Contributed

MEMBERS of a wealthy family suing radio host Alan Jones for defamation over deadly flood claims will have to work with broadcasters to figure out where the case goes next.

Denis, John, Neill and Joe Wagner sued Mr Jones, Radio 4bc Brisbane, journalist Nick Cater, and Harbour Radio over comments made after the devastating January 2011 Queensland floods.

The question of the role of the Wagner-owned Grantham Quarry in the floods will be pivotal to the determination of the dispute.

Justice Peter Applegarth said there is an "essential sting" to what the Wagners claimed were defamations.

The Wagners argue the broadcasts contained "imputations" that wrongly suggest they were to blame for the deaths of 12 people, or for the deadly flood when a quarry wall or levee breached or collapsed.

But lawyers for Mr Jones, Mr Cater and the radio companies rejected claims those meanings were in fact conveyed in the broadcasts.

A newly-published Brisbane Supreme Court decision showed the case was stuck on disputes about what "expert opinion" might be needed to address the lawsuit's major issues.

Issues for experts to weigh in on might include "hydraulic and hydrological phenomena" in Helidon and Grantham, Justice Applegarth said.

The Wagners' lawyers said experts should look at whether the existence or breach of the Wagner-owned Grantham Quarry embankment caused or contributed to the flooding.

The family members also wanted experts to look at whether the existence or breach of that embankment "had a material impact on the damage" the flooding caused.

The Wagners' proposed assumptions include a "no breach" scenario.

That would "assume that the embankment remained fully intact throughout the flood," Justice Applegarth added.

Lawyers for Mr Jones, Mr Cater and the radio stations proposed the experts be asked a series of questions.

But the two sides could not agree on what issues the expert evidence should focus on, Justice Applegarth said.

Topics such as the timing and way the embankment was breached needed to be sorted out, Justice Applegarth said.

He told the parties to work out which issues and assumptions would need expert opinion.

The case will be reviewed on September 14.

As NewsRegional previously reported, a 2014 commission of inquiry cleared the Wagners of responsibility for the floods.

Mr Jones has maintained his actions were those of a journalist acting in a community's best interests after the tragedy.


Topics:  2011 floods alan jones denis wagner grantham grantham quarry harbour radio helidon hydrology inland tsunami joe wagner john wagner neill wagner nicholas charles cater toowoomba

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Tour gives a valuable ag insight

FIRST-HAND: Withcott Seedlings compliance manager Joe Shiels talks to participants of the the pilot AgWork tour.

The pilot AgWork tour was held last week.

Lake Clarendon says no way to bullying

STAND TOGETHER: Principal Susan Wright and school captains Xanthea Kugel and Felicity Boon with the anti-bullying pledge.

Take a stand and say 'No way!' to bullying

Jackson finds his family at Lowood High

STUDENTS' BESTFRIEND: Lowood State High School student Sophie, with the school's beloved assistance dog, Jackson.

Lowood High's fifth school captain is a little different.

Local Partners