Did comedian's Oscar Pistorius joke go too far?

Jimmy Carr stunned crowds at the Q Awards with a controversial joke about Oscar Pistorius.
Jimmy Carr stunned crowds at the Q Awards with a controversial joke about Oscar Pistorius.

THE 200-strong audience at the Xperia Access Q Awards were less than impressed by Jimmy Carr's particularly dark joke about the Oscar Pistorius trial.  

The comedian, 42, made the controversial comment following the athlete's sentencing to five years for the culpable homicide of Reeva Steenkamp on Tuesday.  

Carr started his opening speech with some meandering banter about needing to go to the toilet, but being stopped by a lengthy queue.  

"So frustrating," he said. "All I'm saying is I can see it from Oscar Pistorius' point of view."  

The audience, which included former Smiths guitarist Johnny Marr, Boy George and Kasabian, bristled at his initial remark, only for Carr to continue.  

"That's not the controversial bit," he said. "Here it comes ... I blame her."  

Another uncomfortable lack of reaction followed.   Undeterred by their silence, Carr added: "If she hadn't been in that disabled toilet none of this would have happened."  

"It's the f****** Q Awards, come on," he shouted, after the joke failed to garner quite the reception he was perhaps anticipating.  


Kari-Lee Birrell's final act of love before her death

Truck driver on morphine before crash

Man who tortured partner for 15 hours sent to jail

Wedding photographer bails on big day

Speeding driver gets six years jail for putting a father in wheelchair

"I think it went all right," Carr told The Mirror after the awards had ended. "I'm going to go home and write some new jokes."  

His poorly phrased jest came as legal experts predicted that Pistorius could be set to spend as little as 10 months in jail for shooting his ex-girlfriend dead.  

The "worryingly short" sentence has caused particular concern for women's rights groups, who have called for "robust and urgent action" to ensure that perpetrators of domestic violence are seen to receive adequately proportionate sentences for the severity of their crimes - and that such crimes are taken seriously.  

"Violence against women is a global pandemic with one in three women experiencing violence in her lifetime," Bethan Cansfield, Policy Manager at Womankind Worldwide, told The Independent.  

She added that although Womankind did not comment directly on individual cases of violence, "low levels of convictions and short sentencing given to perpetrators of violence against women is rampant across the world."  

"This violates a woman's right to justice and sends a strong message that states do not take violence seriously.  

"As the Oscar Pistorius trial comes to an end, we hope governments across the globe take robust and urgent action to end violence against women. They should also increase support to women's rights organisations which provide specialist support for women survivors of violence."    

Topics:  editors picks oscar pistorius

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

What's in it for us?

COMMUNITY'S VOICE: ATRC's Lockyer Valley Community Consultative Committee.

Lockyer Valley committee sceptical of Inland Rail

Sheep dairy is top class

GOOD STUFF: Awassi Queensland has been recognised for its sheep milk products for a second year running.

Lockyer sheep dairy recognised by country's best chefs

Next generation of yogis learn in the Lockyer

TUNING IN: Sarah Weber runs her kids yoga class once a week, each term from her Cura Life Studio in Gatton.

Yoga teacher Sarah Weber shares the benefits of starting yoga early.

Local Partners